Pacific vs. Great Lakes Steelhead: A Comparative Study

Image credit:Garrett Morrow

Introduction

Steelhead trout, a migratory form of rainbow trout, are prized by anglers for their fighting ability and the challenge they present. While both Pacific and Great Lakes steelhead belong to the same species, their differences arise from their distinct environments and the historical context of their populations.

Origins and Hatchery Support

Pacific Steelhead

Pacific steelhead are native to the Pacific Ocean watersheds, primarily along the western coast of North America. Their natural habitats include rivers in states such as Washington, Oregon, and California. The Hoh River in Washington is one of the most well-known locations for Pacific steelhead fishing. These fish are primarily wild, having evolved over thousands of years in their native environments. However, due to overfishing, habitat destruction, and other environmental factors, hatchery support has become crucial for their populations. Hatchery programs were introduced to supplement wild stocks and enhance angling opportunities.

Impact of Hatchery Support

Hatchery-raised steelhead are bred and released into the wild to bolster declining populations. These fish often return to their natal rivers to spawn, contributing to the gene pool. However, the introduction of hatchery fish can sometimes lead to genetic dilution and competition with wild populations. Nevertheless, hatchery practices have been adapted to prioritize the genetic integrity of native stocks, thus creating a balance between wild and hatchery fish.

Great Lakes Steelhead

In contrast, Great Lakes steelhead are not indigenous to the region. They were introduced in the late 19th and early 20th centuries as part of fish stocking programs aimed at improving recreational fishing opportunities. Initially, steelhead were introduced from Pacific coastal stocks, primarily from California and Oregon, into various lakes and rivers in the Great Lakes region, including the Salmon River in New York.

Successful Introduction and Wild Propagation

The introduction of steelhead to the Great Lakes has been remarkably successful. Over time, these fish adapted to their new environments, and evidence of natural reproduction began to surface. Today, wild steelhead populations are being recorded, showing that these fish have established self-sustaining populations in several rivers. While hatchery support still exists to maintain fish stocks and enhance fishing opportunities, a significant number of steelhead are now wild, showcasing a successful integration into the Great Lakes ecosystem.

Similarities Between Pacific and Great Lakes Steelhead

Despite their differing origins and environmental conditions, Pacific and Great Lakes steelhead share several similarities:

1. Species Classification: Both are classified as Oncorhynchus mykiss, with similar physical and biological traits.
2. Life Cycle: Both types of steelhead undergo similar life cycles, migrating from freshwater to saltwater and back to spawn.
3. Diet: Their diets are primarily composed of aquatic insects, small fish, and crustaceans, which they forage for in both their juvenile and adult stages.
4. Fighting Ability: Both Pacific and Great Lakes steelhead are renowned for their fighting ability, making them a favorite among anglers.

Differences in Size and Coloration

Size

• Pacific Steelhead: Typically, Pacific steelhead can grow larger than their Great Lakes counterparts. Mature adults can weigh between 8 to 20 pounds, with some exceptional specimens exceeding 30 pounds. The average length ranges from 24 to 36 inches.

• Great Lakes Steelhead: Great Lakes steelhead tend to be slightly smaller, weighing between 5 to 15 pounds, with lengths averaging 20 to 30 inches. However, some fish can still reach sizes similar to Pacific steelhead.

Coloration

• Pacific Steelhead: Pacific steelhead exhibit vibrant colors, particularly during the spawning season. Their bodies are often silver-blue with a distinctive pink stripe along the lateral line. As they prepare to spawn, their colors become more pronounced, with bright red and purple hues emerging.

• Great Lakes Steelhead: Great Lakes steelhead display a similar coloration but are generally less vivid than Pacific steelhead. Their bodies are typically more silvery, especially in younger fish, and the pink stripe may be less pronounced. During spawning, they can also exhibit bright colors, but the intensity varies.

Seasonal Runs

Pacific Steelhead

Pacific steelhead are known for their diverse seasonal runs, which can vary by river and region. There are generally two main runs:

• Winter Run: These fish enter rivers from late fall through early spring. Winter run steelhead tend to be larger and are often targeted by anglers during the colder months.

• Summer Run: Summer run steelhead return to their natal rivers in late spring and summer. These fish are usually smaller than winter run steelhead and are known for their acrobatic fighting style.

Great Lakes Steelhead

Great Lakes steelhead also display seasonal runs, primarily categorized as:

• Spring Run: These fish return to the rivers in late winter and early spring, often coinciding with the thawing of ice. Spring run steelhead are popular among anglers as they tend to be larger and more aggressive.

• Fall Run: Fall run steelhead return to spawn in the fall months, typically from September to November. These fish are often smaller but can be just as aggressive, providing excellent fishing opportunities.

• • Summer Run: Summer-run steelhead are typically from the Skamania strain, but their populations are far smaller and are stocked in fewer rivers compared to fall and winter-run steelhead

Fishing Techniques

Techniques for Pacific Steelhead

Fishing for Pacific steelhead requires different techniques depending on the time of year and the specific river conditions. Some of the most effective methods include:

1. Fly Fishing: This is one of the most popular methods for targeting Pacific steelhead. Anglers often use nymphs, streamers, and dry flies, matching the local insect hatches. The use of a two-handed rod (Spey casting) is common in larger rivers.

2. Drift Fishing: This technique involves casting bait (like roe or worms) and allowing it to drift naturally with the current. This method is highly effective during the winter run when steelhead are less aggressive.

3. Float Fishing: Using a bobber or float to present bait at a controlled depth, float fishing can be particularly productive in slower-moving water.

4. Backtrolling: This method is commonly used in larger rivers. Anglers troll with a boat while presenting lures or bait at various depths, enticing steelhead that are holding in deeper pools.

Techniques for Great Lakes Steelhead

Great Lakes steelhead fishing techniques share similarities, yet they are often adapted to the unique characteristics of the Great Lakes waters:

1. Float Fishing: This method is also popular among Great Lakes anglers. Using slip bobbers, anglers can effectively present bait at the right depth to entice steelhead in rivers and streams.

2. Drift Fishing: Similar to the Pacific technique, drift fishing in the Great Lakes often involves using live bait, such as trout beads or spawn sacks, to mimic the natural food source.

3. Fly Fishing: Fly fishing is effective, particularly during the spring and fall runs. Anglers often use streamers and nymph patterns to target steelhead holding in deeper runs.

4. Casting Lures: Many anglers use spoons, spinners, and plugs to cover more water when targeting steelhead in the Great Lakes. This method allows for quick exploration of various depths and locations.

Renowned Fishing Locations

Pacific Steelhead Locations

1. Hoh River, Washington: Renowned for its stunning natural beauty, the Hoh River is a prime location for both winter and summer run steelhead. The river flows through the Olympic National Park, providing anglers with a unique fishing experience amidst lush forests.

2. Deschutes River, Oregon: This river is famous for its summer run steelhead. Anglers flock here for the opportunity to catch large, aggressive steelhead in scenic canyon settings.

3. Klamath River, California: Home to both wild and hatchery steelhead, the Klamath River offers excellent fishing opportunities, particularly during the fall run.

Great Lakes Steelhead Locations

1. Salmon River, New York: This river is a hotspot for Great Lakes steelhead fishing, especially during the fall and spring runs. The Salmon River is known for its accessibility and the abundance of fish.

2. Brule River, Wisconsin: Famous for its scenic beauty, the Brule River offers excellent steelhead fishing opportunities throughout the year, making it a favored destination for anglers.

3. Grand River, Michigan: A revered location for steelhead fishing, the Grand River offers diverse fishing opportunities, particularly during the spring run.

Shortcuts to search popular fishing terms on Youtube

Search Term	Thumbnail	Link
Steelhead Techniques		Watch Video
Best Live Baits for Steelhead		Watch Video
Steelhead Fishing Strategies		Watch Video
Where to Find Steelhead		Watch Video
Steelhead Fishing Tips		Watch Video